The lowest prices I usually find are online either with partsgeek or drivewire. For your car the lowest price I can find is a remanufactured at http://www.drivewire.com/vehicle/volkswagen-beetle/starter/
The other option you have is a parts yard, depending on your location...look under auto parts and junk yards in your phone book or only by your zipcode. You might find one that way, but remember that its used and doesnt have a warranty.
Answers & Comments
The lowest prices I usually find are online either with partsgeek or drivewire. For your car the lowest price I can find is a remanufactured at http://www.drivewire.com/vehicle/volkswagen-beetle/starter/
The other option you have is a parts yard, depending on your location...look under auto parts and junk yards in your phone book or only by your zipcode. You might find one that way, but remember that its used and doesnt have a warranty.