If indeed it is wired correctly, and your wires go where you think they do, then your Orbit is defective. Test by removing wires 1,2,3, and 4. Push for 1, and touch wire 1 to the connector for 1. Sprinkler 1 comes on? Touch wire 1 to the connector for 2. Sprinkler 1 comes on? If yes to both, then Orbit is broken.
Answers & Comments
If indeed it is wired correctly, and your wires go where you think they do, then your Orbit is defective.
Test by removing wires 1,2,3, and 4.
Push for 1, and touch wire 1 to the connector for 1. Sprinkler 1 comes on? Touch wire 1 to the connector for 2. Sprinkler 1 comes on?
If yes to both, then Orbit is broken.